- ⇧ Introduction
- ⇧ 1. Uploading Rules
- ⇧ 2. Music
The upload rules below appear overwhelmingly long and detailed at first glance. However, their length is for explaining the rules clearly and thoroughly. A summary of each rule is in bold text before the actual rule for easier reading. You may also find the corresponding rule sections in the Index. The corresponding ⇧ (move one level up) and rule section links (move down into the document) help provide quick navigation.
If you are still unsure of what a rule means before uploading something, PLEASE ask at any of the following forms of site user support: First-Line Support, The Help Forum. Privately message a moderator on the site if other support has directed you to a moderator for resolution or support has been unhelpful in your case. If you find any dead links in the upload rules, let a staff member know so it can be promptly fixed.
- ⇧ 1.1.1. Only music uploads are allowed on this site.
- ⇧ 1.1.2. Only upload music if you have the legal right to do so. You may only upload music that you have created yourself, or if it is music that is freely available and allows distribution. Torrents breaking this rule will be removed.
- ⇧ 1.1.3. Duplicate torrents are not allowed. There are some exceptions to this rule, which are outlined in their relevant sections below.
- ⇧ 1.1.4. Seed complete copies. Do not upload a torrent unless you intend to seed until there are at least 1.0 distributed copies. Seeding past this minimum is strongly encouraged.
- ⇧ 1.1.5. No advertisements. Do not advertise other sites in your torrent descriptions, torrent directories, or the contents of your torrent. We have no advertising and neither should you. Exceptions: Additional information about an artist, album, or band is acceptable, and does not count as advertising.
- ⇧ 1.1.6. Archived files in uploads are not allowed.
- ⇧ 1.2.1. You may NOT accept donations for freely available work if you are not the original artist or official representative. This is fraudulent and will result in a warning being issued by site staff. Repeat offenders will be banned.
- ⇧ 1.2.2. +Artist account holders are the only members permitted to receive financial donations for their uploads. This feature can be used by any +Artist account holder, and will be fully activated only after site staff have approved the suitability of the material in question. This is necessary as it prevents us from inadvertently allowing someone to profit from another artist's material.
- ⇧ 1.2.3. Verified and therefore trusted accounts are exempt from the content approval process. In order to have your account upgraded to "verified", you can contact a member of the site staff. This is a privilege given to those account holders with a proven and trusted track record within the site, and can be revoked at any time by site staff if they deem such action necessary.
- ⇧ 1.3.1. Anything not specifically allowed below. If you have any doubts, ask before uploading.
- ⇧ 1.3.2. Videos of any kind. No movies, no TV shows, no concerts, and no data/video tracks from enhanced CDs.
- ⇧ 1.3.3. Pornography or nudity of any kind. This ban includes pictures, erotic comic books or hentai, sex manuals, erotic magazines, etc.
- ⇧ 1.3.4. User compilations in any category. All "packs" must be reasonably official as specified in each category.
- ⇧ 1.3.5. DRM-restricted files: files must not be encrypted or in a restricted format that impedes sharing.
- ⇧ 2.1.1. The only formats allowed for music are those listed below:
- MP3, FLAC, Ogg Vorbis, AAC, AC3, DTS
- ⇧ 2.1.2. No transcodes or re-encodes of lossy releases are acceptable here. There are no exceptions regardless of how rare you claim the release is. The only acceptable transcodes are releases that were transcoded from a lossless source (e.g. CD, SBD, DAT, Vinyl, SACD, LPCM). Exceptions: Official lossy-mastered releases are not considered to be transcodes. They are allowed on the site. It is highly recommended you provide proof in at least one of the following forms: a) digital photo proving ownership of the CD or hi-res scan of the CD top b) a rip log c) confidence of 2 or more verification with AccurateRip in the rip log or after ripping (with arcue.pl / arcue.exe, CUE Tools, or equivalent) in your Release description. You must provide this proof if requested by staff.
- ⇧ 2.1.3. Music releases must have an average bitrate of at least 192kbps regardless of the format. Exceptions: The following VBR encodes may go under the 192kbps limit: LAME -V2, -V1, -V0, APS, APX, MP3 192 (VBR), Ogg Vorbis -q8 (~256 VBR), and AAC ~192 (VBR) to AAC ~256 (VBR) releases.
- Recommendations for MP3 encoding: We strongly encourage the latest Hydrogenaudio recommended stable release of LAME (currently 3.98.3) for MP3 encoding. You can find out more information about LAME and its options at the Hydrogenaudio Wiki.
- Recommendations for Ogg Vorbis encoding: We strongly encourage the use of newer and well-maintained Ogg Vorbis encoders such as Aoyumi's aoTuV series of encoders. However, as long as the encoder satiates the requirements for Ogg Vorbis presets and average bitrates on this site, you may use any encoder you prefer. For more information on aoTuV and other Ogg Vorbis encoders, read the wiki page at Hydrogenaudio.
- Recommendations for AAC encoding: Encoding object types LC/Low Complexity and HE/High Efficiency are strongly encouraged. LC/Low Complexity is recommended for music uploads. You may use other encoding profiles and object types, but they will not be compatible on most portable players, media players, and systems. Find out more information here.
- ⇧ 2.1.4. Bitrates must accurately reflect encoder presets or average bitrate of the audio files. You are responsible for supplying correct format and bitrate information on the upload page. All audio torrents must have accurate labeling for the encoder settings used or the average bitrate. This means that lossy formats such as MP3, AAC, DTS, and Ogg Vorbis cannot have a bitrate of "lossless." Conversely, FLAC cannot have fixed bitrates or xxx(VBR) bitrates. Non-LAME formats and MP3 encoders cannot use LAME's VBR switches (-V0, -V1, -V2, etc). If you are uploading a non-LAME MP3, determine the average bitrate of the files. Then select "Other" for bitrate and type in xxx (VBR) where "xxx" is the bitrate you found. Some tools to determine the bitrates of audio files are Audio Identifier, Mr. Questionman (mirror), or Dnuos. If the bitrate is labeled incorrectly on your torrent, your torrent may be deleted if reported.
- ⇧ 2.1.5. Albums must not be ripped or uploaded as a single track. If the tracks on the original CD were separate, you must rip them to separate files. Clearly, CDs with single tracks are permitted to be uploaded without prior splitting. You are encouraged to use MusiCutter or MP3DirectCut for MP3 and CUE Tools, XLD, or EAC for lossless if you need to split up an album image into individual tracks. Exceptions: Gapless DJ or professional mixes released as MP3+CUE images are allowed as unseparated album images on the site. No other format is allowed in this unsplit form. Unsplit MP3 albums containing separate tracks are not allowed if missing a cue sheet.
- ⇧ 2.1.6. All music torrents must be encoded with a single encoder using the same settings. This means you cannot create a torrent which contains both CBR and VBR files, nor can you upload torrents containing a mix of APS (VBR)/-V2 (VBR) and APX (VBR)/-V0 (VBR). Including other kinds of audio quality, such as duplicate lossy files in a lossless torrent is also prohibited. This kind of release is referred to as a "mutt rip."
- ⇧ 2.1.7. Use only the allowed container formats for audio files. Use .m4a and .mp4 for AAC, and .ogg for Vorbis only. All other formats should not be encapsulated in containers. (e.g. FLAC must not be in an Ogg container, MP3 must not be in an .m4a container, and so forth.) Exceptions: DTS CD-sourced audio rips, although contained in WAV, should have the .dts extension.
- ⇧ 2.1.8. Music not sourced from vinyl must not contain pops, clicks, or skips. They will be deleted for rip/encode errors if reported. Music that is sourced from vinyl must not have excessive problems.
- ⇧ 2.1.9. Freely available music is allowed. Music uploaded may be freely available on the web (come from official sources such as record label, band websites, or the Internet Archive). Uploads can come from other torrent sites, but you take responsibility for determining the music is not transcoded. You are highly encouraged to include a link to the original host site or a note about the source for freely available files. However, this is not required and not grounds for reporting a torrent if missing such a link. All freely available music must conform to quality rules and formatting rules. This means it must be tagged correctly, not be a transcode, be separate tracks, and so forth. Freely available music uploads should have the "WEB" media format if no other source media (e.g. CD, DVD, etc.) can be established for the files.
- ⇧ 2.1.10. Label water-marked or voice-over releases clearly. Watermarks or voice-overs must be clearly indicated in the torrent description. The torrent will be deleted for quality misrepresentation if not noted.
- ⇧ 2.1.11. Radio, television, web rips and podcasts are not allowed. It does not matter whether it's FM, direct satellite, internet, or even if it's a pre-broadcast tape. It's too difficult for staff to moderate such things. Radio does not have enough bandwidth to meet our 192kbps rule. Anything on the radio has already gone through several conversions or re-encodes. Note: Do not confuse web rips for WEB. The "WEB" media label on the upload page is for digital downloads, and has nothing to do with web rips.
- ⇧ 2.1.12. No unofficial audience recordings. Unofficially-mastered audience recordings (AUD) are not allowed here regardless of how rare you think they are. These include recordings on bootleg labels and those mastered by fans or traders. Unofficial IEM (In Ear Monitor), ALD (Assistive Listening Device), Mini-Disc, and Matrix-sourced recordings are also not allowed. None of those are pure soundboard quality either. Exceptions: Officially-remastered AUD/IEM/ALD/Mini-Disc/Matrix recordings are allowed. These may be re-appropriated recordings released with the artist's or their label's consent. Bonus tracks from such recording sources are also exempt since the tracks are released officially with the album.
- ⇧ 2.1.13. Tape (VHS, Video-8, etc.) music sources are not suitable for this site. The frequency range is not good enough to meet the high quality we strive to maintain here. Hi-fi formats of tapes, such as Hi-Fi VHS, have good frequency range above regular standards (near CD quality at times). However, none of these sources are allowed on the site for moderation reasons.
- ⇧ 2.1.14. Cassettes are allowed under strict conditions. Rare releases available only on cassette may be uploaded under strict special conditions. Cassette-sourced uploads must be approved by staff first. You must contact a moderator privately for approval before uploading. Include proof in the form of discography information from a reputable source as well as spectrals of 2 songs in your message. Staff reserves the right to refuse any badly-done cassette rips. Staff will immediately reject any cassette sources with poor lineage such as Audience recordings, bootlegs, or multi-generational rips. Unapproved cassette torrents may be reported and will be deleted if no note exists of prior staff approval. Anyone found falsifying staff notes will have their uploading privileges removed.
- ⇧ 2.1.15. The only lossy multichannel audio formats allowed are AC3 and DTS. If the source is DTS or AC3, do not transcode to other formats. Exceptions: Transcoding is allowed if the source is lossless (LPCM or MLP). Those should be compressed with multichannel FLAC. Note: DTS-CD rips cannot be re-compressed to a lossless codec and they must be kept as WAV files with the .dts extension.
- ⇧ 2.1.16. SACD hybrid rip sources must be properly labeled. SACD hybrid discs ripped from the CD layer should be labeled as CD and not SACD. If you used your CD/DVD drive and a CD ripper (such as EAC) to extract the audio, then label it as "CD" source (i.e. it's not true 24-bit). If the rip came from the genuine digital SACD layer through a SACD player mod or line out, it should be 24-bit quality SACD. You may include "SACD Hybrid" in the Edition Information box on the upload page.
- ⇧ 2.1.17. WEB media is for digital downloads only. Digital downloads released only on the internet from internet sources cannot be given the CD media label on the upload page. This includes downloads from webstores. Freely available music with no source information must also be labeled WEB. If possible, indicate the source of your files (e.g. webstore) in the torrent description. You are responsible that the downloaded files conform to Panda.cd's rules for music quality. Note: Do not confuse WEB for web rips. WEB media torrents are not always web rips (transcodes). Please check the spectrals before assuming they are web rips.
- ⇧ 2.1.18. User-made compilations are not allowed. Compilations must be reasonably official. For example, "34 of my favourite Grateful Dead songs" is not a reasonably official collection. Compiling a release from a list, such as a Top 100 Billboard Chart, is not allowed. User-made and unofficial multichannel mixes are also not allowed. Exceptions: Bootlegs are allowed if they meet quality standards for music and are proven to be retail releases in digital or physical form. Bootlegs/mixtapes assembled and available from internet-only sources (e.g. music blogs, message boards, etc.) are not considered official enough for this site.
- ⇧ 2.1.19. All music torrents must represent a complete album (a complete collection release). Albums must not be missing tracks, or discs in the case of a multi-disc release. All music torrents must be one release. If an album is released as a multiple set of CDs, then it must be uploaded as a single torrent. Uploading each disc separately is not allowed. Digital downloads of albums must consist of entire albums. If tracks are available separately, but not released as singles, you may not upload them individually. Exceptions: Bonus discs may be uploaded separately in accordance with this rule. Please note that individual bonus tracks are not allowed to be uploaded without the rest of the album. Bonus tracks are not bonus discs. Enhanced audio CDs with data or video tracks must be uploaded without the non-audio tracks. If you want to share the videos or data, you may host the files off-site with a file sharing service and include the link in your torrent description.
- ⇧ 2.1.20. Multi-album torrents are not allowed on the site under any circumstances. That means no discographies, Pitchfork compilations, etc. Discographies make it a hassle for users to download individual albums. They result in a lot of duplicate albums being uploaded and are generally very poor quality. If releases (e.g. CD singles) were never released bundled together, do not upload them together. Live SBD material should be one torrent per night, per show, or per venue. Including more than one show in a torrent results in a multi-album torrent. Exceptions: Only official boxsets and official compilation collections can contain multiple albums.
- ⇧ 2.1.21. Edition Information must be provided for digitally-sourced torrents. Digitally-sourced (including CD-sourced) rips of material first released before the availability of their source medium must have accurate edition information. For example, if a CD rip of an album whose original release date was 1957, predating the creation and distribution of CDs, then the uploader must make note of the correct year the CD was pressed, and preferably catalog identification as well. Rips for which Edition Information cannot be provided must be marked as an 'Unknown Release'. Under no circumstances must you guess or feign Edition Information.
- ⇧ 2.1.22. Downsampling of analog rips is allowed. Analog rips that have been downsampled may be uploaded (e.g. a 24/96 vinyl rip downsampled to 16/44). Any downsampled torrents must include the specific programs and methods used to downsample in addition to the lineage for the original rip or it will be deleted. NOTE: downsampling of CDs is expressly forbidden.
- 2.2.0. Overview
This chart is an overview of how the dupe and trump rules work. Thanks goes to lhnz from What.cd for creating it.
- ⇧ 2.2.1. Upload an allowed format if it doesn't exist on the site. If there is no existing torrent of the album in the format you've chosen, you can upload it in any bitrate that at least averages 192kbps.
- ⇧ 2.2.2. Same bitrates and formats of the same releases are duplicates. If a torrent is already up in the format and bitrate you want to upload it in, you are not allowed to upload it–it's a duplicate (dupe). So if there's a 192kbps CBR MP3 version on the site, you are not allowed to upload another 192kbps CBR MP3. You cannot trump an existing torrent with a version that includes album art. Exceptions: Different editions and source media do not count as dupes. Refer to rule 2.2.5. for more information.
- ⇧ 2.2.3. Report all trumped and duplicated torrents. If you trump a torrent or notice a duplicate torrent, please use the report link to notify staff for removal of the old or duplicate torrent. This especially applies to lossless rips. If you are uploading a superior rip to the current one in the same format on the site, report the older torrent and include a link to your torrent in the report. Your torrent will be deleted as a dupe if the older torrent is not reported. Note: Trump = You can trump a torrent that exists on the site by uploading a torrent in a preferred bitrate or quality as specified in the rules below. A torrent that is trumped by another torrent is considered a duplicate ("dupe") of the superior torrent, since the two torrents are not allowed to coexist on the site.
- ⇧ 2.2.4. Dupe rules also apply against previous uploads. All of the following dupe rules concerning music formats in this section may apply to torrents uploaded before. For example, if you upload an album in 192kbps MP3, someone can upload the same album in 320kbps at a later date and trump your 192kbps MP3.
- ⇧ 2.2.5. Different editions and source media count as separate releases. A rip from a different medium (e.g. vinyl) or release (e.g. a remaster) of an already existing torrent counts as a different release. The dupe rules do not apply between the two different edition torrents, nor two differently sourced torrents. So if a FLAC ripped from a CD is already up, you are still allowed to upload a FLAC ripped from vinyl. And if a 320kbps CBR MP3 release of an original mastering of an album was uploaded, you are still allowed to upload a 320kbps CBR MP3 remaster.
- ⇧ 2.2.6. Complete or untouched releases replace incomplete or watermarked versions. Watermarked promos containing voice-overs and similar can be trumped by a non-watermarked release. Releases missing hidden tracks or pre-gaps can be replaced by proper rips that include the range. Note that this does not apply to de-clicked and unmodified vinyl rips.
- ⇧ 2.2.7. Bonus disc-only uploads can co-exist with the complete set in accordance with the trumping rules. A bonus disc-only release can be trumped by an upload containing the "full" original album + bonus discs, in the same format, in accordance with the usual trump rules.
- ⇧ 2.2.8. Higher bitrate CBR (Constant Bitrate) and ABR (Average Bitrate) torrents replace lower ones. Once a CBR (Constant Bitrate) rip has been uploaded, no CBR rips of that bitrate or lower can be uploaded. In the same manner, once an ABR (Average Bitrate) rip has been uploaded, no ABR rips of that bitrate or lower can be uploaded. For example, if a 320kbps CBR rip is already on the site, you are not allowed to upload a 256kbps CBR. ABR and CBR may be interchangeably trumped. A CBR can trump a lower bitrate ABR and an ABR may trump a lower bitrate CBR. You may not upload a 192kbps CBR if a 256kbps ABR of the same release is already up.
- ⇧ 2.2.9. Lossy format torrents with .log files do not replace equivalent existing torrents. If you want to upload a lossy format (e.g. MP3, Ogg Vorbis, AAC, etc.) with a log that already exists in the same medium and edition, you may not replace the current lossy torrent. For example, a -V2 (VBR) MP3 torrent with a log cannot replace a -V2 (VBR) without a log. Same applies for lossy audio torrents with .m3u, .cue, and other additions such as artwork. Exceptions: If an existing torrent contains encode/rip errors, you may upload another copy without errors. The bad torrent needs to be reported or yours will be deleted as a dupe. Also, see rules 2.3.8 through 2.3.16 for replacing badly named and tagged torrents.
- ⇧ 2.2.10. Vinyl Specific Dupe Rules
- ⇧ 126.96.36.199. Only one lossy vinyl rip in a specific bitrate is allowed per release. Once someone has uploaded a lossy-format vinyl rip (in MP3, Ogg Vorbis or AAC), you may not upload another copy in the same bitrate. It does not matter whether if the lossy files are of a different sample rate found on the site. For example, if a 48 kHz -V2 (VBR) copy is already up, you may not upload the same album in -V2 (VBR) at 44.1 kHz.
- ⇧ 188.8.131.52. Lossless de-clicked and unmodified versions of the same vinyl release may co-exist on the site. De-clicked and unmodified vinyl rips of the same edition/release do not count as dupes. Clearly indicate de-clicking was used in the torrent description (and the Edition Information box if possible). This only applies to lossless vinyl formats (e.g. FLAC) releases, not lossy ones (e.g. MP3).
- ⇧ 184.108.40.206. Only one lossless and one 24bit lossless vinyl rip is allowed per edition. A poor sounding lossless rip may be trumped by a better sounding lossless rip, regardless of lineage information. The same quality trump can occur for 24bit lossless rips. To trump a rip for a better sounding version, you need to report it with clear informations about how your rip sounds better than the other one. Rips of extremely poor quality may be deleted outright if reported. All quality trumps/deletions of this nature are at the discretion of the moderator involved.
- ⇧ 2.2.11. MP3 Specific Dupe Rules
- ⇧ 220.127.116.11. -V0 (VBR), -V2 (VBR), and 320 CBR MP3 are allowed at any time. You may upload a -V0 (VBR), -V2 (VBR) or 320 CBR MP3 as long as another rip with the same bitrate and format doesn't already exist. So if a -V0 (VBR) is on the site, you may still upload a -V2 (VBR) or 320 CBR MP3 of the same release.
- ⇧ 18.104.22.168. -V2 (VBR) and APS (VBR) replace CBR rips under 256kbps, 192 (ABR), and rips averaging 192 (VBR) to 210 (VBR). Once a rip with either -V2 (VBR) or APS (VBR) LAME encoding preset has been uploaded, you are not allowed to upload any CBR torrents under 256kbps bitrate. Furthermore, a -V2 (VBR) or APS (VBR) rip will trump all indiscriminate VBR rips of similar bitrate. A -V2 (VBR) rip will replace a 192 (VBR) rip or 210 (VBR) rip for example. Also, a -V2 (VBR) will replace a 192 (ABR) torrent.
- ⇧ 22.214.171.124. -V0 (VBR) and APX (VBR) replace CBR rips under 320kbps, V1 (VBR), all (ABR) rips, and all other non-LAME preset (VBR) rips. Once a rip with either -V0 (VBR) or APX (VBR) LAME encoding preset has been uploaded, you are not allowed to upload any CBR torrents under 320kbps bitrate. Furthermore, a -V0 (VBR) or APX (VBR) rip will trump all indiscriminate VBR rips (of 192kbps average bitrate or higher). A -V0 (VBR) rip will replace a 256 (VBR) rip for example. You may not upload a -V1 (VBR) LAME encoding preset if either -V0 (VBR) or APX (VBR) are already present.
- ⇧ 126.96.36.199. Non-LAME preset (VBR) rips do not replace each other. Similar bitrate (VBR) encodes are considered dupes. Thus, a 192 (VBR) is allowed to co-exist with a significantly higher (VBR) encode. You may not upload a 224 (VBR) if a 256 (VBR) is already present, nor vice versa.
- ⇧ 188.8.131.52. -V2 (VBR) and -V0 (VBR) LAME encodes trump APS (VBR) and APX (VBR) respectively. -V2 (VBR) trumps an APS (VBR) encode of the same release. Once a -V2 (VBR) is uploaded, you may not upload an APS (VBR) encode. -V0 (VBR) trumps an APX (VBR) encode of the same release. Once a -V0 (VBR) is uploaded, you may not upload an APX (VBR) encode.
- ⇧ 2.2.12. Ogg Vorbis Specific Dupe Rules
- ⇧ 184.108.40.206. Only -q8.x (VBR) and equivalent presets (-q0.8) are allowed. Only -q8.x (~256 (VBR)) is allowed on the site for Ogg Vorbis. Torrents encoded with presets other than -q8.x will be deleted. You may use fraction presets where x is any number from 0 - 9. Fraction presets do not make your upload unique from all similar presets. You may not upload a -q8.1 (VBR) if a -q8.7 (VBR) is already present.
- ⇧ 2.2.13. AAC Specific Dupe Rules
- ⇧ 220.127.116.11. No constant bitrate encodes higher than 320 CBR are allowed on the site. You may upload AAC files from 192kbps to 320kbps if no torrent exists in that format for a release. Any CBR bitrates under 192kbps and bitrates higher than 320kbps will be deleted. CBR trumping rules apply to AAC as well. See 2.2.8 for more information.
- ⇧ 18.104.22.168. Encoding profiles/object types at the same bitrate are not unique uploads. A 256 (VBR) in LC profile is a dupe if an 256 (VBR) HE object type encode already exists on the site. Similarly, different extensions (.m4a and .mp4) count as dupes if available in the same bitrate.
- ⇧ 22.214.171.124. VBR AAC encodes can be trumped by 320 CBR encodes. Any (VBR) encode regardless of encoder used may be deleted in favor of 320 CBR encodes. This includes 320 (VBR) encodes or encodes made with Nero preset of approximately -q0.80.
- ⇧ 2.2.14. Lossless Specific Dupe Rules
- ⇧ 126.96.36.199. All FLAC CD rips must come from official CD sources. Rips must be taken from commercially pressed or official-pressed CD sources. They may not come from CD-R copies of the same pressed CDs. Undetected errors may be introduced from the original CD rip and subsequent burning process to CD-R. Even though the CD-R is ripped with proper settings in XLD or EAC, it may still be a sub-par rip with a good log. Exceptions: If the release is only distributed on CD-R, then that is acceptable. Promotions and small distributions of albums tend to be in CD-R format.
- ⇧ 188.8.131.52. A FLAC torrent without a rip log can be trumped by a FLAC torrent of the same release containing a rip log. The FLAC torrent without a log will be trumped in favor of one containing a log. Please make sure your rip log has the extension .log in order to be displayed properly on the torrents page. Exceptions: If the FLAC torrent with a log contains excessive rip errors (e.g. suspicious positions, skips, or pops), it cannot replace the existing torrent. Audiochecker, auCDtect, and other MPEG analyzer logs do not count as rip logs, even if renamed with the .log extension. Soundboards and other exclusive lossless digitally-distributed files cannot be unofficially burned to CD-R and re-ripped in order to trump existing digital copies of the same quality and source.
- ⇧ 184.108.40.206. A FLAC upload with an EAC or XLD rip log that scores 100 on the logchecker replaces one with a lesser score. Proper EAC or XLD rips can replace rips made by other rippers or with sub-par settings. No log scoring less than 100 can trump an already existing one under 100. For example, a FLAC+log rip that scores a 50 in the logchecker can not be trumped by a FLAC+log that scores an 80. Panda.cd recommends xuncat's guide for EAC. Panda.cd strongly encourages enabling AccurateRip if available for your CD extraction app of choice. Note: If a log scores 95 due to not defeating audio cache, and the torrent description contains accepted proof of the drive for ripping caches less than 64 kB of audio data, then that torrent can not be trumped by a torrent with a 100 score. The 95 torrent may be upgraded to 100 once a staff member has been alerted to the case, and has manually corrected the score. See 220.127.116.11.
- ⇧ 18.104.22.168. XLD and EAC log in languages other than English require manual logchecker score adjustment. The current logchecker cannot parse non-English logs made by EAC and XLD. However, a special exception is made for foreign-language logs since the rip quality is equivalent to English logs. Please report your torrent with the Report link so staff can approve your torrent manually.
- ⇧ 22.214.171.124. Range rips of hidden tracks or range rips under strict conditions require manual score adjustment. The new logchecker cannot accurately score range-ripped hidden tracks appended to proper rip logs. If you have created a 100 rip with a hidden track, but the logchecker decreased your score for the hidden track, report the torrent. That way your score can be adjusted to reflect the proper settings. Panda.cd does not encourage ripping entire CDs as range rips. Instead, please rip CDs to separate tracks according to the EAC Guide. For those rare cases where you have created a CD image rip with matching CRCs for test and copy, and the tracks have a AccurateRip verification of 2 or more, then you may submit your torrent for manual adjustment. Note: The CD Image rip must be split with CUE Tools, XLD, or EAC. No other splitter is acceptable for a score adjustment. You will not receive score adjustment for copy-only range rips approved with AccurateRip nor range rips done with test and copy only.
- ⇧ 126.96.36.199. A 100% log rip (created from EAC v0.99 or newer) lacking a cue sheet can be replaced by another 100% log rip with a noncompliant cue sheet ONLY when the included cue sheet is materially different than 'a cue generated from the ripping log' http://eachelper.uphero.com/index.php. Examples of a material difference include additional or correct indices, and pre-emphasis flags. If you upload a torrent with a cue sheet that provides nothing additional beyond what is contained in the ripping log of the preexistent torrent, it will be deleted as a dupe.
- ⇧ 188.8.131.52. Drives that cache less than 64 kB of audio data may leave the audio cache enabled. Proof is required. They can be trumped by a 100 rip if no proof is included. Under certain conditions, rips made without the audio cache disabled may trump other rips if all other settings are correct. A pasted log (hosted at Pastebin or similar site is OK) or screenshot of proof from Feurio! and a screenshot from CacheX should be posted in the torrent description field. You will need to present proof from both CacheX and Feurio!. EAC's own cache detection may give erroneous results sometimes, so a screenshot of EAC's drive features test cannot serve as proof. Also, XLD logs before CDParanoia III 10.2 engine require AccurateRip verification because the cache is not properly defeated on earlier CDParanoia versions. Please report your torrent with the Report link so staff can approve your torrent manually to 100 score.
- ⇧ 184.108.40.206. CD rips that score less than 100 due to ID3 tags or non-compliant tags for FLAC may be trumped by same score rips that have faulty tags removed and replaced with the standard for each format. Enabling ID3 tags in EAC when ripping to FLAC may prevent some players from playing the files due to the inclusion of ID3 headers. If you wish to trump a FLAC rip that was ripped with ID3 tags enabled, upload the corrected torrent with the proper Vorbis comments, and report the old torrent. Add information about your clean-up in the Release description, or your torrent may be deleted for a dupe. Do not edit the log and change the ID3 tag setting to "No." Note: A simple way of getting rid of the ID3 header is to decompress the files to WAV. Then compress the files to FLAC, and again add the proper Vorbis comments.
- ⇧ 220.127.116.11. No log editing is permitted. You may change the path of the files to hide your username or personal info in the home directory (e.g. C:\Documents and Settings\MyRealName\My Documents\) after ripping if need be. No other log editing is permitted. Forging log data is a serious misrepresentation of quality, and will result in a warning and permanent loss of upload privileges if found. Do not consolidate logs under any circumstances. If you must re-rip a disc and happen to have the new log appended to the original, leave them as-is. Do not remove any part of either log, and never copy/paste parts of a new log over an old log. If you find that an appended log has not been scored properly, please PM a moderator to get the score manually adjusted.
- ⇧ 2.2.15. Unknown Release torrents may be trumped by seemingly identical torrents whose Edition Information can be verified. Torrents marked as 'Unknown Release' are eligible to be trumped by rips sourced from the same medium, of the same track listing and running order, whose source Edition Information is provided and can be verified.
- ⇧ 2.3.1. Music releases must be in a directory containing the music. No music contained in an archive (e.g. .rar, .zip, .tar, .iso). Exceptions: There is no need for a directory for a torrent that consists of a single file (and is not an archive!).
- ⇧ 2.3.2. Name your directories with meaningful titles, such as "Artist - Album (Year) - Format." We advise that directory names in your uploads should at least be "Artist - Album (Year) - Format". The minimum acceptable is "Album", although it is preferable to include more information. If the directory name does not include this minimum then another user can rename the directory, re-upload and report yours for deletion. Avoid creating unnecessary nested folders (such as an extra folder for the actual album) inside your properly named directory. Nested folders make it less likely that downloaders leave the torrent unchanged in order to stay seeding.
- ⇧ 2.3.4. Torrents should never have [REQ] or [REQUEST] in the title or artist name. If you fill a request using the proper Requests system, then everyone who voted for it will be automatically notified.
- ⇧ 2.3.5. Torrent album titles must accurately reflect the actual album titles. Use proper capitalization when naming your albums. Typing the album titles in all lowercase letters or all capital letters is unacceptable. Exceptions: If the album has special capitalization, then you may follow that convention.
- ⇧ 2.3.6. The Artist field in the torrent name should contain only the artist name. Any descriptions like [Advance] or [CDM] (if you must use them) should be entered in the Edition Information box on the upload page, not the title. Do not add additional information about the artist in the artist field unless the album credits the artist in that manner. For example, "Artist X (of Band Y)" or "Band X (feat. Artist Y)." It is recommended that you search existing torrents for the artist name so that you can be sure that you name the artist the exact same way. A torrent with a proper artist name will be grouped with the existing torrents on the artist page, and thus easy to find. Labeling the artist incorrectly prevents your torrent from being grouped with the other torrents of the same artist.
- ⇧ 2.3.7. The year of the original recording should be used for the upload page "Year" box. Use the recording year for "Year of the original release" (if you can establish it), and use the option to add the release year for the album or edition you are uploading in the Edition information on the uploads page. For example, all editions of The Beatles (White Album) would have 1968 in the main Year box. However, each of the various mono pressings, remasters, re-releases, expanded editions, reconstructions, etc. would have its respective release year in the Edition Information box.
- ⇧ 2.3.8. All lossless analog rips should include clear information about source lineage. All lossless SACD digital layer analog rips and vinyl rips must include clear information about recording equipment used. If you used a USB turntable for vinyl, clearly indicate you have. Also include all intermediate steps up to lossless encoding, such as program used for mastering, sound card used, etc. Lossless analog rips missing rip information can be trumped by better documented lossless analog rips of comparable or better quality. In order to trump a lossless analog rip without a lineage, this lineage must be included as a .txt or .log file within the torrent.
- ⇧ 2.3.9. All lossless soundboard recordings must include clear information about source lineage. This information should be displayed in the torrent description. Optionally, the uploader may include the information in a .txt or .log file within the torrent. Lossless soundboard recordings missing lineage information will be deleted if reported.
- ⇧ 2.3.10. File names must accurately reflect the song titles. You may not have file names like 01track.mp3, 02track.mp3, etc. File names with incorrect song titles can be trumped by properly labeled torrents. Note that these must be substantial improvements such as the removal of garbage characters. Small changes such as diacritical marks are insufficient grounds for trumping. English translations of song titles in file names are encouraged, but not necessary for foreign language song titles. Exceptions: Rare albums featuring no track listing or untitled tracks may have file names like 01track.mp3, 02track.mp3, and so forth. Please note this tracklist in the Album description. If foreign language characters create playback problems for some systems or cannot be coherently translated, file names such as "01track" is acceptable for those few cases.
- ⇧ 2.3.11. Including track numbers of each song in the file names (e.g. "01 - TrackName.mp3") is highly recommended. If a torrent without track numbers in the file names is uploaded, then a torrent with the track numbers can take its place. Exception: Track numbers are not required for single-track torrents.
- ⇧ 2.3.12. Multiple-disc torrents cannot have tracks with the same numbers in one directory. Tracks cannot contain duplicate track numbers in the same directory. You may either place the tracks for each disc in a separate directory or number the tracks successively. You may place all the tracks for Disc One in one directory and all the tracks for Disc Two in another directory. If you prefer to use one directory for all the audio files, you must use successive numbering. Successive numbering may consist of the following (as illustrated with examples). Disc One has 15 tracks and Disc Two has 20. You may either number tracks in Disc One as #01-#15, and those of Disc Two as #16-#35 in the same directory. Or you may add a Disc number before the track numbers, such that the numbers are #1 06 for Disc One Track 06, and #2 03 for Disc 2 Track 03, and so forth. That way the track numbers will not be duplicated across multiple discs.
- ⇧ 2.3.13. Properly tag your music files. Certain meta tags (e.g. ID3, Vorbis) are required on all music uploads. Make sure to use the proper format tags for your files (e.g. no ID3 tags for FLAC – see rule 18.104.22.168). ID3v2 tags for files are highly recommended over ID3v1. If you upload an album missing one or more of these tags, then another user may add the tags, re-upload, and report yours for deletion. The required tags are:
- Track Number.
Note: The "Year" tag is optional, but strongly encouraged. However, if missing or incorrect, is not grounds for trumping a torrent.
- ⇧ 2.3.14. The torrent artist for classical works should use the full composer name. Use the composer for "Artist" unless the album is a recital or contains works by several composers. Do not add the conductor or performer(s) to the composer's name as artist - you may add him/her/them at the end of the album title, though, in order to make it easier to distinguish between different recordings of the "same" work.
- ⇧ 2.3.15. Newly re-tagged torrents trumping badly tagged torrents must reflect a substantial improvement over the previous tags. Small changes that include replacing ASCII characters with proper foreign language characters with diacritical marks, fixing slight misspellings, or missing an alternate spelling of an artist (e.g. excluding "The" before a band name) are insufficient grounds for replacing other torrents. You may trump a release if the tags do not follow the data from a reputable music cataloging service such as Musicbrainz or Discogs. In case of conflict between reputable listings, either tagged version is equally preferred to the site and cannot trump the other. For example, an album is tagged differently in Musicbrainz and in Discogs. Either style of tagging is permitted; neither is "better" than the other. In that case, any newly tagged torrents replacing an already properly tagged torrent, which follows good tagging convention, will result in a dupe. Exceptions: Classical music has no easy tagging standard due to the incompatibilities with ID3 tag formats and classical meta data. Those may follow any standard as long as the tags are reasonable (i.e. not cut off, not misspelled beyond a few simple errors, not overly ambiguous, or uninformative). If you are not sure, you may follow guidelines at sites such as MusicBrainz, HydrogenAudio, this article, or this article. Note: The MusicBrainz guide for classical tagging may result in overly long tags, file names, and folder names. Some OSes (notably Windows), cannot read long folder and file names. It is advised to use it with ID3v2 and other tags that support long track names. However, use caution when naming the folders and files themselves.
- ⇧ 2.3.16. Avoid embedding large images if including cover art in meta tags. Do not embed large images (in excess of ~256 KB) in file meta tags. It adds unnecessary bloat to the files. Include the artwork in a separate directory if too big or hi-res. If someone reports your torrent for large embedded artwork, it will be deleted.
|Upload||This is the section of the rules regarding all content allowed on this site.|
|Clients||These are the clients we allow to connect to our tracker and rules specific to them.|
|Tagging||These rules govern what tags can and can not be added.|